Understanding Insurance Bad Faith and What Policyholders Need to Know

David Senoff, founding partner of First Law Strategy Group, has spent nearly three decades litigating appellate cases, insurance bad faith claims, and public policy matters across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and federal courts nationwide. In this discussion, he explains what insurance bad faith really means, how insurers use denial tactics, and the remedies available to policyholders, plaintiffs, and institutions when an insurer acts unreasonably.

What does insurance bad faith mean?

Many people assume that a denied claim automatically signals insurance bad faith. However, that is not always the case. Insurance companies are legally permitted to deny claims if they believe the claim falls outside the coverage of the policy.

Bad faith arises when an insurer denies a claim without a reasonable basis—and either knows or should have known that denial was improper. In simple terms: if the company had no valid reason but denied the claim anyway, it may constitute bad faith.

What tactics do insurance companies use to avoid paying claims?

David Senoff outlines two frequent tactics insurers use:

  1. Immediate Denials – Claims denied so quickly that it raises doubts about whether the file was even reviewed.
  2. Delays and Excessive Paperwork – Repeated document requests designed to frustrate policyholders. When claimants comply but are still denied due to “insufficient information,” this may signal intentional bad faith.

These strategies often pressure policyholders into accepting lower settlements or abandoning claims altogether.

What legal remedies are available to policyholders?

In Pennsylvania, statutes protect policyholders against bad faith denials. If proven that an insurer acted intentionally or recklessly, several remedies are available:

  • Interest on the claim amount
  • Attorney’s fees and litigation costs, often paid directly by the insurer
  • Punitive damages, which are uncapped in Pennsylvania and designed to punish insurers for intentional misconduct

Punitive damages can significantly increase the financial consequences for insurers, sometimes multiplying the value of the original claim five to six times.

What are some examples of insurance bad faith in action?

Insurance bad faith can appear in many situations, such as:

  • Life Insurance Claims – Offering a settlement far below the policy’s face value after a policyholder’s death.
  • Car Accident Cases – Presenting unreasonably low offers despite clear liability.
  • Health and Welfare Funds – Denials that impact not just one individual but entire groups, such as unions or employer-based plans.

In many cases, what appears to be an “individual decision” by an insurer is actually part of a larger company-wide policy to limit payouts.

How does insurance bad faith affect more than just individuals?

Bad faith practices extend beyond individual claimants. They can affect unions, healthcare funds, large employers, doctors, and even lawyers. When an insurer enforces restrictive policies—such as refusing coverage for certain medications—it impacts every member under that plan, not just a single policyholder.

When should policyholders involve a bad faith attorney?

Trial lawyers often encounter red flags suggesting insurer interference. For example, in medical malpractice cases, a doctor may choose a less effective treatment because the insurer would not approve or pay for the better option. In such situations, involving a lawyer experienced in bad faith litigation can be critical.

Policyholders and firms are advised not to confront insurers aggressively at the first suspicion of bad faith. Instead, the prudent course is to have an experienced attorney review the case, identify patterns of misconduct, and determine whether a separate bad faith claim is warranted.

Final Thoughts

Insurance bad faith undermines trust and harms not only individuals but also institutions. With the right legal strategy, policyholders can pursue remedies, hold insurers accountable, and secure fair outcomes.

For more information or assistance with potential bad faith claims, visit First Law Strategy Group at firstlawstrategy.com.