Insurance bad faith occurs when an insurer denies a valid claim—such as auto, life, health, or disability coverage—without a legitimate reason, fully aware that no valid basis exists for the refusal. For instance, a policy clearly covers a prescription drug, yet the insurer rejects it by claiming the diagnosis falls outside coverage, despite contractual obligations.
Common Tactics Insurers Use to Delay or Deny Claims
Insurers employ two primary forms of bad faith. In first-party claims, such as denied medications or procedures, companies repeatedly demand additional information from policyholders or doctors, including obscure items like medical journals. They may slightly alter denial reasons over time, creating a pattern of deny-delay-deny until appeals exhaust.
In third-party claims, like a multi-car accident where the policyholder bears no fault—sandwiched between vehicles—an insurer might refuse coverage entirely. This leaves the policyholder without legal representation, unpaid damages if sued, or settlement support, forcing personal defense against claims.
Legal Consequences for Insurers Acting in Bad Faith
Pennsylvania and select states impose strict penalties with proven evidence. Courts mandate payment of the original claim, plus attorney fees, interest accrued from initial denial to judgment, and punitive damages in egregious cases. These extras punish misconduct and deter future violations, with amounts varying by claim size.
Do Lowball Settlement Offers Indicate Bad Faith?
Lowball offers sometimes reflect standard negotiation—starting below value expecting counteroffers. However, persistent lowballing, minimal increments, or refusal to budge despite clear higher value signals deeper issues, hinting at intentional undervaluation.
Impact of Bad Faith on Individuals vs. Large Groups Like Unions
Bad faith harms everyone, but individual denials affect one person’s immediate needs. For union health funds or large institutions covering thousands, a single policy change—such as excluding a medication—ripples group-wide, amplifying harm across numerous policyholders compared to isolated cases.
Remedies Available When Courts Rule Bad Faith
Successful claims yield the full claim amount dollar-for-dollar. Courts add attorney fees, interest on unpaid sums from denial date onward, and potentially substantial punitive damages. A $10,000 claim might escalate to $60,000 or more, including multipliers. For high-cost items like surgeries in life, health, or disability policies, base amounts reach tens of thousands, magnifying total penalties three to five times when approval could have prevented escalation.
When Trial Lawyers Should Involve Bad Faith Specialists
Engage bad faith counsel early in suspicious denials, especially unexplained lowballs in auto cases. In health scenarios, medical malpractice attorneys sometimes uncover insurance overlays—doctors aware insurers reject treatments like specific chemotherapy, omitting options or prescriptions. This breaches doctor-patient duties while constituting bad faith interference.
First Steps for Policyholders or Firms Suspecting Bad Faith
Document every interaction meticulously. Send letters and emails seeking written denial reasons, copying via certified mail to prevent “never received” defenses. Avoid assuming single extension requests prove bad faith—overwork explains isolated delays—but multiple extensions warrant scrutiny. Experienced reviewers distinguish routine backlog from patterns, guiding next actions effectively.